Too Many Ideas? Here’s What to Do When You Can’t Choose

Reading Time: minutes

I could feel a frustration in her voice and see it in her eyes.

Decision paralysis occurs when facing choices feels overwhelming, leading to avoidance or inaction rather than commitment. This inability to choose often stems from fear of making the wrong decision, perfectionism, or having too many seemingly equal options, creating a stuck state where postponing the decision feels safer than moving forward with uncertainty.

โ€œIโ€™ve never felt as though I canโ€™t find my passion.โ€ she said, โ€œMy problem is the opposite. I have too many passions. I have too many great ideas. I just can’t choose and actually do something. Thatโ€™s where I get stuck.โ€

You wouldnโ€™t believe how often I hear this, and variations of it. It shouldn’t be a surprise because most of us have felt it at some point.

We can often get stuck wavering between options and hoping to find the perfect solution. We have all these ideas but weโ€™re hoping that one idea will trump all of the others and win out as our one and only passion. Unfortunately, this search for a single perfect solution can lead to analysis paralysis, where we become so overwhelmed that we fail to make any decision at all. Instead of fixating on that elusive ideal, we should consider embracing the journey of exploring alternative choices in life. By allowing ourselves to experiment with different paths, we may uncover passions we never recognized, leading to a more fulfilling experience overall.

The problem is this: weโ€™re looking at the ideas and trying to decide between them when no idea is going to change how we feel.

Instead of asking: which should I pursue? You need to ask: why canโ€™t I decide?

What keeps you feeling like you can’t choose? Whatโ€™s the fear that keeps you stuck? What are the stories that you are telling and retelling yourself about choosing, missing out, or whatever it might be?

In the comments, have you ever felt stuck with too many ideas? What’d you do to find your way? Click here to comment.

(Photo by Jay Mantri/CC Zero)

Why can’t I make decisions even when I have good options?

Decision paralysis often comes from perfectionism, fear of regret, or the belief that one perfect choice exists if you just think long enough. The abundance of options can also create analysis paralysis where comparing possibilities feels safer than committing to one path.

How do I overcome decision paralysis?

Set decision deadlines, recognize that no choice is permanent, focus on ‘good enough’ rather than perfect, and remember that indecision is itself a decision with consequences. Often taking action on a good option teaches you more than endlessly analyzing from the sidelines.

What if I make the wrong choice?

Most choices aren’t permanently life-defining. What feels like a crucial fork in the road is often just one decision among many that shape your path. Making a choice and learning from it typically creates better outcomes than avoiding decisions altogether.

Is it better to make any decision than no decision?

Generally yes, because action provides information and momentum that overthinking cannot. While reckless choices aren’t ideal, thoughtful action on a reasonable option usually beats indefinite deliberation. You can course-correct once you have real-world feedback.
  1. You’ve put helpful language to what seems to be THE story of my adult life as it relates to finding meaningful work. So many desires, so many pulls, endless thoughts of pursuit with very little actual movement. Thanks for the words, Dan. You nailed it, yet again ๐Ÿ™‚ So glad you chose something and moved forward into helping the rest of us on our journey toward more meaning in our lives and work ๐Ÿ™‚

    1. Thanks so much, Ryan! It means a lot to have you say so. Hopefully one of the take aways here is that your experience is our experienceโ€” that you’re not alone in the struggle. ๐Ÿ™‚

      The task for you (and me) is to continue to unearth and explore the narratives that keep us caught between the options.

  2. THATS THE WHOLE REASON IM HERE I CANNOT DECIDE AND I WAS RELYING ON YOU TO TELL ME

    1. Sorry to disappoint, but it sounds like there’s more going on here, right? You can weigh the positives and negatives and explore the options, but often what keeps us from choosing is not about the choices at all, but about fear and insecurity. It’s time to face yours ๐Ÿ™‚

  3. Dan,
    I’m first of all relieved to know that I’m not the only one on the planet with this issue. I too was looking for answers on your page…

    I think about what will gratify me, that is, which of the ideas will satisfy my most fundamental needs and desires most quickly.

    This past Friday I listed the top 5 things I’m pursuing , that I feel passionate about . I felt I was making progress to tame my wild mind. Still, in spite of my intentions, I did very little over the weekend and woke up this morning to all of them competing for my attention – “do me,”, “no, do me instead,” they seem to call out.

    My head burned and I prayed to God for help once again. Then I did a little tapping (Emotional Freedom Technique) for a few seconds. I felt a little relief and I thought about finding a practitioner.

    I could feel the anxiety and fear. Anxiety about how much time I lose in deciding which will bring me income and personal fulfillment and fear about the consequences of having no money.

    It’s clearly the feelings of anxiety and fear that I need to work on – not what should I do. I’ll do some more tapping on my own. It works.

  4. I have descions I can't figure out or answer to.im undecidable if this Or this way .I get stuck 5o were I go 5o my room isolaat

Comments are closed.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

Related Articles

Get Weekly Encouragement